Do Muriel and Seymour legitimately talk that often?.What does Seymour plan to do on vacation?.Along with that, meaningful and not extra dialogue as portrayed by Muriel and her mother’s conversation, and descriptive wording for insight into characters as to show and not tell, portrayed by Muriel’s actions and recollections during the call. That is a great technique in writing, and I applaud Salinger’s use of it, it’s definitely a technique to mimic in our own writing. Little, almost unnoticeable details like that make the reader feel rewarded for discovering them, and that keeps them engaged. We were just told that Seymour had done strange things and that her mom was worried, there was randomly a physiatrist in the hotel with his wife, and that Muriel just went to grab a smoke and crossed her legs. We were not explicitly told that Seymour was mentally unstable, or that Muriel didn’t feel the need to talk to the physiatrist in the hotel in case Seymour went insane, or that Muriel gradually became nervous and unsure of herself during the course of her call with her mother. JD Salinger is very adept at conveying information through details and recollections that his characters have. Seymour is mentally unstable, likely due to his time in the army, and that explains his previous actions, as well as his future ones. Their points of view, her mother being worried for Muriel, and Muriel reassuring herself and her mom that Seymour will be perfectly fine, lead to very important information about Seymour that give his actions later in the story much more clarity. They also discuss how Seymour was in the army, what he did to Muriel’s grandma’s chair, and how he is generally unstable. They discuss his mental state and her mom brings up that, during their last doctor visit, the doctor said that Seymour was on the verge of completely losing control. One example is when, Muriel, a main character, was talking with her mom about her husband, Seymour. Specifically, when the two worked hand and hand to progress the story. The author’s use of concrete details when describing the point of view of the characters, and speed at which the plot progressed made it very enjoyable to read. This story was engaging, and kept me invested in it the whole time. Once he is back in his room, Seymour demonstrates his insanity one last time, by taking, loading, and killing himself with his pistol. Exiting the water, Sybil runs back to her mother in the hotel, and after a small period of time, Seymour follows. Once they are in the water, the young man describes to Sybil what a bananafish is, giving the reader a glimpse of his insanity, and after Sybil is convinced she sees one, the fellowship dissolves quickly. Sybil says goodbye and runs down the beach, and Seymour leaves as well.Īfter a meandering conversation on the beach, Seymour and Sybil wade into the water. Sybil says that she has seen a bananafish, and Seymour decides that it’s time to leave the water. ![]() Sybil believes that Seymour should have pushed her off, but Seymour finds such an action to be impolite and also points out that, unlike Sybil, she has not been cruel to a dog belonging to another customer at the hotel. ![]() They also have an exchange about Sharon Lipschutz, another little girl who Sybil saw sitting next to Seymour while he was playing the piano. They go into the water together, and he tells her about bananafish, which are fish that swim into holes with a lot of bananas in them, eat all of the bananas, become trapped in the hole, and die. The conversation ends with Muriel assuring that her mom that she’s fine, and with her mom begrudgingly accepting.Ī little girl named Sybil Carpenter runs off down the beach and finds Seymour, Muriel’s husband, after her mother puts sun tan oil on her. The two talk over the phone of Muriel’s father, her situation at the hotel, and their concerns for one another. Muriel is on a vacation with her newly-wedded husband, Seymour, and her mother is concerned about her daughter’s safety. Salinger, begins with a call from one of the story’s main characters, Muriel’s, mom. ![]() “A Perfect Day for A Bananafish,” by J.D. A Presentation by Benjamin Arthur, Vera Caldwell, and Olivia Barnes
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |